WHY ESTABLISH AN

Inclusive research group?

Researchers succeed in inclusive environments.

Early career researchers, such as graduate students and postdocs, learn and succeed in environments where they feel valued and where they are able to ask questions and express new ideas. Creating an inclusive work environment for early career researchers can lead to better research outcomes and increase the persistence of these researchers in their fields. In addition, inclusive research group climate can contribute to increasing the retention of researchers from underrepresented groups in STEM.

The day-to-day environment for graduate students and postdoctoral researchers is heavily influenced by others within the same research group because group members often work on similar research questions, share research techniques, and may share lab or office space. While the culture of a research group is set collectively by all group members, the research group leader can lead by example and set in place expectations for members that encourage and enable inclusive practices. Below are practical tips for group leaders to create and sustain an inclusive research group.

one

Set a group culture

Be explicit about what types of topics you are willing to discuss or advise on.

For instance, students may be uncomfortable bringing up issues related to identity with faculty members who have not explicitly indicated they are available to discuss such issues.1

Seek to understand differences among group members in a non-judgmental way.

Celebrating diversity means valuing unique individuals, and the perspectives they bring to the table. Encourage group members to share their past experiences and how those experiences relate to topics of interest.

Encourage group members to get together outside of work,

which creates opportunities to gain greater understanding of each other’s backgrounds and cultures. See our related guide on peer mentoring for more information.2

Download the Research Group Checklist

Click the button below to get your copy of the checklist in a printable format to post up.
DOWNLOAD CHECKLIST
Download all the checklists
two

Provide resources and clear policies

Establish an information repository to provide informational resources to all group members.

Such a repository ensures all group members have equal access to informational resources.

  • Some groups have a lab manual to make students aware of norms, for instance around work-life balance or what to do when they make mistakes.3
  • Information can also be easily managed through a document-sharing platform, such as Google Drive, Dropbox, or Slack.

Explicitly define your expectations to help you be consistent in what you ask of each group member.

Do you expect everyone in your group to teach? Or contribute to department or other organizational efforts? Be clear and consistent about such expectations.

Whenever you make a commitment to anyone in your group, make sure to write it down and follow up.

It may not seem important to you, but could be very important to your group member.4

Ensure equitable distribution of group tasks

(e.g., maintaining lab and office spaces, updating the group website, etc.).

Have a ‘chore list’ with each member signed up for 1-2 tasks; assignments should change occasionally (once per year) so no one gets ‘stuck’ with the most time-consuming or least desirable work.5

Download the Research Group Checklist

Click the button below to get your copy of the checklist in a printable format to post up.
DOWNLOAD CHECKLIST
Download all the checklists
three

Run inclusive group meetings

Make sure all members of your group have the opportunity to participate.

  • At a minimum, every person should be given a chance to ask a question to the presenter.
  • Even better, start group meetings with check-in’s from your group members: each person gives a 30-60 second update from the past week that may or may not be research-related. This helps (a) group members want to participate in meetings, (b) keep everyone in the group more knowledgeable about each other's’ work, and (c) provide an opportunity for students to bring up aspects of their identities that they otherwise might not have a space to share.

Be cognizant of and interrupt interruptions.6

 

Make sure you know and use the correct gender pronouns for everyone in your group.

Correct others when appropriate.7

Affirm the work of students presenting at group meetings

(e.g., “I know those results required a lot of work and persistence”).

Give constructive feedback.

Approaches vary (and it’s worth discussing feedback styles as a group). If you are very critical in your feedback, make sure your group members know that it is intentional and intended to help them learn. Starting your response to a presentation by saying one specific aspect you liked before pointing out an area for improvement can help motivate students to improve, though it is important not to be seen as sugarcoating.

Download the Research Group Checklist

Click the button below to get your copy of the checklist in a printable format to post up.
DOWNLOAD CHECKLIST
Download all the checklists
four

Communicate effectively

Remember that communication styles vary from person to person,

in both one-on-one and group settings. Discuss your preferred communication style with your group members and provide suggestions on what they can do to maximize the effectiveness of their communication with you. Try to understand how your group members’ style(s) may differ from your own.8

Download the Research Group Checklist

Click the button below to get your copy of the checklist in a printable format to post up.
DOWNLOAD CHECKLIST
Download all the checklists
five

Connect your group members to opportunities

Get to know your students to understand what each student wants to get out of their degree program,

and think about ways that you can help meet their professional and/or personal goals.

Consistently and equitably provide opportunities to your group members.

Discuss the types of opportunities available to find out what will be interesting and useful for each individual rather than making assumptions. Track how often you support different members to present at conferences, co-author grant applications or papers, or guest lecture.

Introduce students and postdocs to both junior and senior members of your network.

Making such connections helps junior researchers build an engineering identity and sense of community and belonging. You can make these connections:

  • At conferences.
  • When people you know visit campus.
  • When a group member’s research relates to the work of other researchers you know (you can suggest they reach out or even provide them with an email introduction).

Give credit to group members who contributed

when presenting on research from your group.

Download the Research Group Checklist

Click the button below to get your copy of the checklist in a printable format to post up.
DOWNLOAD CHECKLIST
Download all the checklists
six

Ask for input

Provide a forum, at least once per year, for students to give suggestions on group policies and meeting structure, and adjust accordingly.

  • Actively invite questions or concerns so group members will feel comfortable coming forward with suggestions.4
  • Consider having a group retreat (either on campus or off) to discuss research group-related issues. It is up to you to show you are interested in what your group members have to say and willing to make changes for a healthier work environment.5

 




References

  1. Mehta, Devang. Lab heads should learn to talk about racism. Nature 559, 153 (2018) https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05646-4
  2. Powell, Kendall. These labs are remarkably diverse - here’s why they’re winning at science. Nature 558, 19-22 (2018) https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05316-5
  3. Aly, Mariam. The key to a happy lab life is in the manual. Nature 561, 7 (2018) https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06167-w
  4. Austin, Jim. Managing knowledge workers: Rules for absolute beginners. Science magazine (2003) https://www.sciencemag.org/careers/2003/05/managing-knowledge-workers-rules-absolute-beginners
  5. Geiger, R. Stuart. Best Practices for Fostering Diversity & Inclusion in Data Science. Berkeley Institute for Data Science Blog (2019) https://bids.berkeley.edu/news/best-practices-fostering-diversity-inclusion-data-science
  6. Dubin, Hilary. How to counteract 3 types of bias and run inclusive meetings. Atlassian blog. (2019) https://www.atlassian.com/blog/teamwork/how-to-run-inclusive-meetings
  7. Gender Pronouns Information. Washington University in St. Louis Diversity and Inclusion. https://students.wustl.edu/gender-pronouns-information/
  8. Perez, Joel; Johnstone, David M. When conflict crosses cultural lines: How culture informs conflict. Staff Publications - Student Life. (2017) https://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://www.google.com/&httpsredir=1&article=1033&context=student_life_works

Download the Research Group Checklist

Click the button below to get your copy of the checklist in a printable format to post up.
DOWNLOAD CHECKLIST
Download all the checklists

Download the Research Group Checklist

Click the link below to get the checklist to print out and display as a reminder of these best practices to help create a more inclusive environment.
DOWNLOAD CHECKLIST
Download all the checklists
Top
As people continuously learning and striving toward equity and inclusion, we welcome your feedback on these tools.
Please send your feedback to:
CONTACT US
© 2021 ReNUWIt.org
crossarrow-rightarrow-up-circle